Halloween Gifts Under $25

Shop the maker

Halloween Gifts Under $25

A limited seasonal edit of handmade earrings and small-batch gifts priced at $25 or less. Bats, ghosts, spiders, black cats, pumpkins, and autumn favorites—curated for easy gifting and spooky-season style.

Many pieces are available in very limited quantities.

Shop collection

Customers are saying

4.88 ★ (114)
Verified

Filter

Category
Clear All
Apply
Filter
Halloween Cookie Studs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 1
New
Shop Something Earthy
Halloween Cookie Studs
$10.00
Sage Spider Studs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Sage Spider Studs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Sage Spider Studs
$10.00
Ivory Spider Studs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Ivory Spider Studs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Ivory Spider Studs
$10.00
Bat Cameo Olive handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Bat Cameo Olive handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Bat Cameo, in Olive
$18.00
Bat Cameo Black handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Bat Cameo Black handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Bat Cameo, in Black
$18.00
Ghost Dogs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 3
Ghost Dogs handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 3
New
Shop Something Earthy
Ghost Dogs
$22.00
Ghost Outline Hoops handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Ghost Outline Hoops handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Ghost Outline Hoops
$18.00
After Dusk Black handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
After Dusk Black handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
After Dusk, in Black
$22.00
After Dusk Sage handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
After Dusk Sage handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
After Dusk, in Sage
$22.00
Bat Cameo Plum handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Bat Cameo Plum handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Bat Cameo, in Plum
$18.00
Avery Autumn Blooms handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Avery Autumn Blooms handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Avery, in Autumn Blooms
$25.00
Autumn Bears handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Autumn Bears handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Autumn Bears
$22.00
The Dragon’s Tome handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
The Dragon’s Tome handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
The Dragon’s Tome
$25.00
After Dusk Cinnamon handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
After Dusk Cinnamon handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
After Dusk, in Cinnamon
$22.00
Dancing Skeleton Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Dancing Skeleton Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Dancing Skeleton Stamps
$20.00
Ghost Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Ghost Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Ghost Stamps
$20.00
Black Cat Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Black Cat Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Black Cat Stamps
$20.00
Haunted House Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Haunted House Stamps handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
New
Shop Something Earthy
Haunted House Stamps
$20.00
Skelepups handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Skelepups handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Skelepups
$22.00
Spooky Sweets Dangles handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 3
Spooky Sweets Dangles handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 3
New
Shop Something Earthy
Spooky Sweets Dangles
$22.00
Harvest Moon handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Harvest Moon handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Harvest Moon
$20.00
Taylor Haunted Harvest handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Taylor Haunted Harvest handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Taylor, in Haunted Harvest
$25.00
Bat Cameo Ivory handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Bat Cameo Ivory handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Bat Cameo, in Ivory
$18.00
Skelekittens handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 1 of 2
Skelekittens handmade polymer clay earrings by Shop Something Earthy — view 2 of 2
Pre-Order
New
Shop Something Earthy
Skelekittens
$22.00
You've viewed 24 of 26 result
Load more

Keep exploring

Explore more collections featuring this maker

Discover more ways to shop products from this maker through related Main Street Collective collections.

Budget-Friendly Finds: $25 & Under
Related collection Budget-Friendly Finds: $25 & Under Shop collection
Earrings
Related collection Earrings Shop collection
Earrings
Related collection Earrings Shop collection
New This Week
Related collection New This Week Shop collection
North Carolina Gifts & Local Makers
Related collection North Carolina Gifts & Local Makers Shop collection
North Carolina Jewelry
Related collection North Carolina Jewelry Shop collection
Shop Something Earthy | Hypoallergenic Clay Earrings
Related collection Shop Something Earthy | Hypoallergenic Clay Earrings Shop collection
Southern Handmade Jewelry
Related collection Southern Handmade Jewelry Shop collection